Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property wfLog::$loginsTable is deprecated in /home/www/htdocs-ssl/forest-of-scholars/app/lib/wordfence/lib/wfLog.php on line 91 Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property wfLog::$blocksTable is deprecated in /home/www/htdocs-ssl/forest-of-scholars/app/lib/wordfence/lib/wfLog.php on line 92 Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property wfLog::$lockOutTable is deprecated in /home/www/htdocs-ssl/forest-of-scholars/app/lib/wordfence/lib/wfLog.php on line 93 Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property wfLog::$throttleTable is deprecated in /home/www/htdocs-ssl/forest-of-scholars/app/lib/wordfence/lib/wfLog.php on line 94 Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property wfLog::$statusTable is deprecated in /home/www/htdocs-ssl/forest-of-scholars/app/lib/wordfence/lib/wfLog.php on line 95 Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property wfLog::$ipRangesTable is deprecated in /home/www/htdocs-ssl/forest-of-scholars/app/lib/wordfence/lib/wfLog.php on line 96 Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property acf_field_oembed::$width is deprecated in /home/www/htdocs-ssl/forest-of-scholars/app/lib/advanced-custom-fields/includes/fields/class-acf-field-oembed.php on line 31 Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property acf_field_oembed::$height is deprecated in /home/www/htdocs-ssl/forest-of-scholars/app/lib/advanced-custom-fields/includes/fields/class-acf-field-oembed.php on line 32 Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property acf_field_google_map::$default_values is deprecated in /home/www/htdocs-ssl/forest-of-scholars/app/lib/advanced-custom-fields/includes/fields/class-acf-field-google-map.php on line 33 Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property acf_field__group::$have_rows is deprecated in /home/www/htdocs-ssl/forest-of-scholars/app/lib/advanced-custom-fields/includes/fields/class-acf-field-group.php on line 31 Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property wfBrowscap::$_source_version is deprecated in /home/www/htdocs-ssl/forest-of-scholars/app/lib/wordfence/lib/wfBrowscap.php on line 97 Increasing Levels of “Hype” Language in Grant Applications and Publications - 学者の杜 | Forest of Scholars, University of Tsukuba

Increasing Levels of “Hype” Language in Grant Applications and Publications

代表者 : MILLAR NEIL JAMES  

A research team led by the University of Tsukuba analyzed the use of “hype” in published abstracts describing the results of all projects funded by the US National Institutes of Health (NIH) from 1985 to 2020. The use of hype adjectives (e.g., novel, groundbreaking, exciting, rigorous, and so on) has consistently increased in correlation with the use of hype language in corresponding grant applications. The findings suggest that increasing salesmanship in research communication is (in part) a downstream effect of language choices made at the grant application stage.
Tsukuba, Japan—The success of scientific endeavors often depends on support from public research grants. Successful applicants increasingly describe their proposed research using promotional language (“hype”); however, it remains unclear whether they use hype in their subsequent research publications.

A research team led by the University of Tsukuba analyzed all published research abstracts of projects funded by the US National Institute of Health (NIH) from 1985 to 2020. The analysis covered 139 hype adjectives emphasizing significance (e.g., imperative, paramount), novelty (e.g., revolutionary, ground-breaking), scale (e.g., massive, vast), rigor (e. g., careful, sophisticated), utility (e.g., impactful, seamless), attitudes (e.g., incredible, exciting), and the gravity of problems (e.g., dire, devastating). A dramatic growth in almost all hype terms was found over the 36-year period. Furthermore, the usage trends of hype adjectives were closely correlated with the usage trends in NIH funding applications during the same period. This finding suggests that the language choices of investigators at the grant application stage affect the subsequent presentation of research findings.

The study indicates the role of funding mechanisms in shaping the tone of research communication. Recognizing the concerns surrounding increasing levels of hype, funding bodies are urged to not nudge investigators towards salesmanship.

###
This work was supported by JSPS KAKENHI (Grant number 21K02919)

 

Original Paper
Title of original paper: Promotional language (hype) in abstracts of publications of NIH funded research Journal: JAMA Network Open DOI: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.48706

Correspondence
Associate Professor Neil Millar
Institute of Systems and Information Engineering, University of Tsukuba